* = Mid-States Football Association Conference Game
^ = NAIA Playoff Game
# = NCCAA Victory Bowl
1993
Record: 2-6-1
Coach: Joe Palmisano
9/4 @Bethany (WV) 23-23
9/18 MT. ST. JOSPEPH (OH) 6-42
9/25 @Bluffton 9-17
10/2 @Urbana 20-38
10/9 @St. Xavier (IL) 45-7
10/16 TIFFIN 16-30
10/23 @Taylor (IN) 35-45
10/30 GENEVA (PA) 21-38
11/5 CROWN (MN) 48-3
1994
Record: 7-3
Coach: Joe Palmisano
9/3 @Westminster (PA)* 21-36
9/10 BETHANY (WV) 40-13
9/17 @Mt. St. Joseph (OH)* 14-21
9/24 ST.XAVIER (IL)* 30-0
10/1 URBANA * 42-16
10/8 @Bluffton 32-13
10/15 @Tiffin* 27-30
10/22 TAYLOR (IN)* 57-30
10/29 @Geneva (PA)* 25-18
11/5 @Thiel (PA) 39-6
1995
Record:10-1-1
Coach: Mike Gravier
9/2 @Taylor (IN)* 42-3
9/9 @Wilmington* 34-14
9/23 TRINITY INT'L (IL)* 24-21
9/30 @Urbana* 56-6
10/7 @Tri-State (IN)* 70-7
10/14 TIFFIN* 19-0
10/21 WESTMINSTER (PA)* 13-13
10/28 GENEVA (PA)* 14-13
11/4 THIEL (PA) 31-10
11/11 WALSH* 10-8
11/18 GENEVA (PA)^ 24-23
12/2 @Findlay^ 7-15
1996
Record: 8-2
Coach: Mike Gravier
9/7 @Lambuth (TN) 38-34
9/14 BAKER (KS) 45-7
9/27 @Iowa Wesleyan 35-12
10/5 FINDLAY 10-13
10/12 TRI-STATE (IN)* 59-14
10/19 @Walsh* 12-2
10/26 GENEVA (PA)* 26-25
11/2 @Tiffin 37-12
11/9 URBANA* 34-6
11/16 @Westminster( PA)* 3-23
1997
Record: 5-5
Coach: Mike Gravier
9/6 LAMBUTH (TN) 16-26
9/13 WEST LIBERTY (WV) 18-35
9/27 TRINITY INT'L (IL) 32-0
10/4 @Geneva (PA)* 12-33
10/11 TIFFIN* 21-0
10/18 @Urbana* 42-7
10/25 WESTMINSTER (PA)* 0-21
11/1 @Taylor (IN)* 19-7
11/8 @Tri-State (IN)* 30-23
11/15 WALSH* 6-14
1998
Record: 7-4
Coach: Mike Gravier
9/12 @West Liberty (WV) 35-24
9/18 ST.JOSEPH (IN) 34-51
9/26 @St. Ambrose (IA) 30-40
10/3 @St. Francis (IN)* 55-30
10/10 ST. XAVIER (IL) 42-34
10/17 TRI-STATE (IN)* 7-21
10/24 @Walsh* 28-21
10/31 GENEVA (PA)* 31-28
11/7 @Tiffin* 37-15
11/14 URBANA* 49-7
11/21 @Georgetown (KY)^ 41-46
1999
Record: 4-6
Coach: Steve Saulnier
9/4 ALLEGHENY (PA) 7-0
9/11 @St. Francis (IL) 26-14
9/18 @St. Joseph (IN) 6-12
10/2 WALSH* 0-15
10/9 @Geneva (PA)* 3-17
10/16 TIFFIN* 9-14
10/23 @Urbana* 20-0
10/30 ST.FRANCIS (IN)* 14-30
11/6 IOWA WESLEYAN 43-42 ot
11/13 @Tri-State (IN)* 9-27
2000
Record: 4-7
Coach: Steve Saulnier
9/2 @Bluffton 42-28
9/9 CAMPBELLSVILLE (KY) 24-28
9/16 @McKendree (IL) 13-45
9/23 ST.FRANCIS (IL) 31-21
9/30 @Walsh* 33-35
10/7 GENEVA (PA)* 29-17
10/14 @Tiffin* 20-28
10/21 URBANA* 16-28
10/28 @St. Francis (IN)* 10-48
11/4 @Wash. & Jeff. (PA) 21-36
11/11 TRI-STATE (IN)* 10-7
2001
Record: 2-8
Coach: Steve Saulnier
9/8 @Campbellsville (KY) 15-34
9/15 McKENDREE (IL) 10-24
9/22 @St. Francis (IL) 17-7
9/29 WALSH* 9-50
10/6 @Geneva (PA)* 23-32
10/13 TIFFIN* 19-25
10/20 @Urbana 22-10
10/27 ST.FRANCIS (IN)* 17-58
11/3 WASH. & JEFF. (PA) 14-43
11/10 @Tri-State (IN) 14-42
2002
Record: 4-6
Coach: Dan Hanson
9/7 THIEL (PA) 13-9
9/21 TRINITY INT'L (IL) 41-7
9/28 @Olivet Nazarene (IL) 45-21
10/5 @Walsh* 22-29 2-ot
10/12 GENEVA (PA)* 10-17
10/19 @Thomas More (KY) 7-14
10/26 URBANA* 52-10
11/2 @St. Francis (IN)* 27-33
11/9 @Taylor (IN)* 21-35
11/16 TRI-STATE (IN)* 7-21
2003
Record: 2-8
Coach: Dan Hanson
9/6 @Georgetown (KY) 20-42
9/20 @Trinity Int'l (IL) 17-24
9/27 OLIVET NAZARENE (IL) 35-30
10/4 WALSH* 36-44 5-ot
10/11 @Geneva (PA)* 6-42
10/18 THOMAS MORE (KY) 14-6
10/25 @Urbana* 17-48
11/1 ST. FRANCIS (IN)* 14-36
11/8 TAYLOR (IN)* 9-13
11/15 @Quincy (IL)* 14-46
2004
Record: 4-6
Coach: Dan Hanson
9/11 CHARLESTON (WV) 33-26
9/18 @St. Xavier (IL) 17-34
9/25 ST. FRANCIS (IL) 30-7
10/2 @Walsh* 17-27
10/9 GENEVA (PA)* 7-13
10/16 @Ohio Dominican* 39-32
10/23 URBANA* 27-30
10/30 @St. Francis (IN)* 6-40
11/6 @Taylor (IN)* 15-23
11/13 QUINCY (IL)* 38-35
2005
Record: 3-7
Coach: Dan Hanson
9/10 CUMBERLANDS (KY) 21-28
9/17 ST. XAVIER (IL) 14-37
9/24 @St. Francis (IL) 34-27
10/1 WALSH* 16-34
10/8 @Geneva (PA)* 15-14
10/15 OHIO DOMINICAN* 13-27
10/22 @Urbana* 34-42
10/29 ST. FRANCIS (IN)* 7-28
11/5 TAYLOR (IN)* 34-32
11/12 @Quincy (IL)* 9-48
2006
Record: 7-4
Coach: Mike Gardner
9/2 TRINITY INT'L (IL) 25-7
9/9 AZUSA PACIFIC (CA) 6-31
9/16 @St. Xavier (IL) 24-21
9/30 GENEVA (PA)* 22-13
10/7 @Ohio Dominican* 17-41
10/14 URBANA* 27-24 ot
10/21 @St. Francis (IN)* 13-34
10/28 @Taylor (IN)* 28-14
11/4 SETON HILL (PA) 28-16
11/11 @Walsh* 20-10
11/18 @North Greenville (SC)# 28-56
2007
Record: 8-4
Coach: Mike Gardner
9/1 @Trinity Int'l (IL) 32-27
9/8 @Azusa Pacific (CA) 21-28
9/15 UNION (KY) 55-21
9/22 OLIVET NAZARENE (IL) 41-21
9/29 @Marian (IN)* 45-28
10/6 TAYLOR (IN)* 33-14
10/13 WALSH* 42-35 ot
10/20 @Urbana* 21-7
10/27 @St. Xavier (IL)* 20-36
11/3 ST. FRANCIS (IN)* 17-31
11/10 @Ohio Dominican* 21-31
11/17 @Geneva (PA)# 45-17
2008
Record: 6-4
Coach: Mike Gardner
9/13 @Union (KY) 28-35
9/27 @Olivet Nazarene (IL) 43-3
10/4 MARIAN (IN)* 45-37
10/11 @Taylor (IN)* 42-17
10/18 @Walsh* 24-21
10/25 URBANA 22-6
11/1 ST. XAVIER (IL)* 27-23
11/8 @St. Francis (IN)* 24-45
11/15 OHIO DOMINICAN* 24-34
11/21 @Northwestern (MN)# 44-49
2009
Record: 3-6
Coach: Mike Gardner
9/12 ST. AMBROSE (IA) 14-34
9/26 @Anna Maria (MA) 65-10
10/3 ST. FRANCIS (IN)* 14-42
10/10 TAYLOR (IN)* 17-23
10/17 @St. Xavier (IL)* 31-66
10/24 WALSH* 14-31
10/31 TRINITY INT’L (IL)* 48-12
11/7 @Marion (IN)* 24-28
11/14 @Olivet Nazarene (IL)* 57-35
2010
Record: 3-7
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/2 @Tiffin 21-31
9/11 @St. Ambrose (IA) 7-28
9/18 ANNA MARIA (MA) 69-0
10/2 @St. Francis (IN)* 17-23
10/9 @Taylor (IN)* 7-12
10/16 SAINT XAVIER (IL)* 16-55
10/23 @Walsh* 21-24
10/30 @Trinity Int'l (IL)* 34-0
11/6 MARIAN (IN)* 7-28
11/13 OLIVET NAZARENE (IL)* 56-21
2011
Record: 4-7
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/1 TIFFIN 40-34 ot
9/10 @McKendree (IL) 30-27
9/17 ST. AMBROSE (IA) 22-24
9/24 MARIAN (IN) 0-56
10/1 @Concordia (MI) 27-0
10/8 ST. XAVIER (IL) 10-52
10/15 @Walsh 10-35
10/22 @St. Francis (IN) 10-47
10/29 @Notre Dame 31-23
11/5 QUINCY (IL) 35-38
11/12 TAYLOR (IN) 13-27
2012
Record: 1-9
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/8 SAGINAW VALLEY ST. (MI) 14-37
9/15 @Hillsdale (MI) 10-27
9/22 WAYNE ST. (MI) 14-38
9/29 TIFFIN 33-27 ot
10/6 @Walsh 7-34
10/13 @Lake Erie 24-35
10/20 ASHLAND 7-31
10/27 NOTRE DAME 19-36
11/3 @Findlay 14-38
11/10 @Ohio Dominican 7-56
2013
Record: 2-9
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/7 @Notre Dame (OH) 31-37
9/14 @Saginaw Valley St. (MI) 20-59
9/21 HILLSDALE (MI) 16-41
9/28 @Wayne St. (MI) 27-38
10/5 @Tiffin (OH) 30-34
10/12 WALSH (OH) 28-38
10/19 LAKE ERIE (OH) 55-50
10/26 @Ashland (OH) 20-27
11/2 @Alderson Broaddus (WV) 59-42
11/9 FINDLAY (OH) 21-35
11/16 OHIO DOMINICAN 13-40
2014
Record: 1-10
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/6 @Ohio Dominican 14-59
9/13 MICHIGAN TECH 6-37
9/20 WAYNE STATE (MI) 15-39
9/27 @Tiffin 21-23
10/4 @Ashland 13-42
10/11 NORTHERN MICHIGAN 42-35 OT
10/18 @Walsh 13-35
10/25 LAKE ERIE 34-55
11/1 @Urbana 16-35
11/8 FINDLAY 0-38
11/15 @Northwood (MI) 17-41
2015
Record: 0-10
Coach: Eric Hehman
9/3 OHIO DOMINICAN 21-59
9/12 @Michigan Tech 27-28
9/19 @ Wayne State (MI) 21-56
9/26 TIFFIN 24-27 OT
10/3 ASHLAND 17-42
10/10 @Northern Michigan 13-41
10/17 WALSH 7-24
10/24 @Lake Erie 24-27 OT
11/7 @Findlay 17-49
11/14 NORTHWOOD (MI) 21-28
2016
Record: 1-8
Coach: Fred Thomas
9/3 TAYLOR (IN) 39-33 OT
9/10 @Truman State (MO) 3-35
9/17 NOTRE DAME (OH) 21-49
9/24 @ Robert Morris (PA) 19-21
10/1 @ Saint Francis (PA) 10-52
10/8 ALDERSON BROADDUS (WV) 16-35
10/22 @ Walsh 21-24
11/5 @ Kentucky Wesleyan 30-40
11/12 @ West Alabama 7-56
2017
Record: 1-9
Coach: Fred Thomas
9/2 @Taylor (IN) 21-28
9/16 @Shaw (NC) 27-34
9/23 MISSOURI S&T 21-48
9/30 OHIO DOMINICAN 3-20
10/7 @Alderson Broaddus (WV) 24-31
10/14 KENTUCKY WESLEYAN 30-34
10/21 @Lake Erie 24-13
10/26 FINDLAY 0-49
11/4 @Hillsdale (MI) 7-45
11/11 WALSH 24-38
2018
Record: 2-8
Coach: Fred Thomas
9/1 CONCORDIA (MI) 27-42
9/8 LAKE ERIE 42-12
9/22 @Kentucky Wesleyan 38-44
9/29 HILLSDALE 35-45
10/6 @Tiffin 21-38
10/13 @Ohio Dominican 17-57
10/20 @Millersville 38-34
10/27 ALDERSON BROADDUS (WV) 55-60
11/3 @Findlay 17-63
11/10 WALSH 22-27